In Praise of the Eye, Window of the Soul
To lose sight is to lose the beauty of the world; the poet and painter debate anew
The chapter [24] 'Of the eye' extols sight as the organ in which the beauty of the universe is mirrored, keeping the soul content within its human prison, so that whoever loses it is left in a dark prison bereft of the sun's light and all nature's works. Leonardo insists that anyone would sooner lose hearing and smell than the eye, though losing hearing forfeits the sciences that end in words. The following rubric [25] opens the dispute of poet and painter: the poet says his science is invention and measure, and the painter answers that painting bears the very same obligations. The whole page is continuous prose in Melzi's fair-copy hand with no drawings.
On this page
The eye mirrors the beauty of the universe
In the eye the beauty of the universe is mirrored, and through it the soul stays content within the human body; whoever loses sight is left in a dark prison, without hope of seeing the sun again. Many hate the brief darkness of night, so what would they do if darkness were their life's companion? Anyone would rather lose hearing and smell than the eye, whose office is to hold the surfaces of bodies that reflect within it.
[25] Poet and painter each claim invention and measure
The poet says his science is invention and measure — invention of matter and measure in the verses — and that he then clothes himself with all the sciences. The painter answers that painting has the very same obligations: invention in the matter he must feign, and measure in the things painted so that they are not out of proportion. The dispute over the two arts is thus renewed.
