Shadows on faces and the quality of the light
Wet streets tint flesh-shadows yellow; why moderate light best serves painting
A page from Part Five of the Treatise on Painting, on the light and shade of flesh. Leonardo warns that a face lit near wet streets picks up their yellowness and darkness in its shadows, so the tones no longer match the true flesh. He then compares strong light (sun or firelight), which makes works crude and graceless, with moderate light of evening or an overcast sky, which is soft and flattering, concluding that the extremes of light and dark are both faulty and the middle is best.
On this page
How wet streets tint the shadows of a face
A face may be well coloured or pale while its shadows turn yellowish. This happens because wet streets are more yellow than dry ones, and the parts of the face turned toward such streets take on the yellowness and darkness of the streets that lie before them.
Why moderate light is best for painting flesh
A body seen by a strong light, such as sunlight or firelight at night, shows the greatest difference between its lights and shadows; this is little to be used in painting because the works remain crude and without grace. A body in moderate light, at evening or under cloud, shows little difference, and such works are soft and lend grace to every kind of face. Too much light makes the work crude and too much dark hides it, so the middle is good.
