The Two Mean Proportionals Between Two Lines
Two solutions to the classic problem, one after Parmenion, disciple of Apollonius of Perga, citing Euclid's Elements VI.
Both leaves are devoted to the ancient problem of finding two mean proportionals between two given straight lines a b and b c, the construction underlying the duplication of the cube. Leonardo works one solution with a semicircle and a completed rectangle b d, proving the result through rectangles inscribed in the semicircle and Euclid's Elements Book VI. He then copies an alternative method attributed to Parmenion, disciple of Apollonius of Perga, using diagonals and an isosceles triangle. Lettered figures in the right margins of both leaves support the demonstrations.
On this page
Finding two mean proportionals between two straight lines
The stated problem: given two straight lines, to find the two mean proportionals between them. This is the construction that underlies the classical duplication of the cube.
Semicircle-and-rectangle construction with points a,b,c,d,f,g
Given lines a b and b c, the rectangle b d is completed and the diagonal a c drawn; a semicircle a d c e is described and through d a line f g is drawn with f d equal to c g. Leonardo proves c g and a f are the mean proportionals using rectangles under the semicircle and Elements VI.
Parmenion's alternative method after Apollonius of Perga
An alternative (aliter) attributed to Parmenion, disciple of Apollonius of Perga: with a b double b c, the rectangular parallelogram d b is completed, the diagonals a c and b d drawn, a b and b c produced to f g, and f g fitted through d.
The chain of continued proportion a b : c g : a f : c d
The demonstration closes on the required continued proportion, showing that as a b is to c g, so c g is to a f, and a f to c d, with d c equal to a b and a d equal to b c. Thus the two means stand between the given lines in continued ratio.
