Compressing a cylinder: how its base widens as its height falls
A volume-conserving construction using a great square and a semicircle a 9 7
A dense geometrical demonstration argues that a square-based cylinder keeps its volume when squashed: as its height is lowered by a half, a quarter or an eighth, its base broadens by the same fraction. Working with a solid of 9 cubes labelled e f g h i K L m S, Leonardo lowers the cylinder n c to the height b c, then uses a 'great square' built on the side n c and a semicircle a 9 7 struck over a graduated scale to find, geometrically, the enlarged side of the base, invoking a proposition of Euclid. The figure at the right pairs a quarter-circle arc with a ladder-like column of graduated cells carrying the letters K, L, x and the numbers used in the proof. Marginal jottings continue the construction and record measures such as a b 8 high 1 and b c 2.
On this page
Volume conserved as the cylinder is lowered
It is proved that as much as the height of the cylinder diminishes, so much it gains in width of base. Taking cylinder n c down to the lowness b c removes eight ninths of its height (the sides e f g h i K L m), leaving side S; adding sides o p of 3 cubes and squaring them restores the 9 cubes of the whole cylinder.
Great square and semicircle a 9 7 for the new base
By the rule of the great square made from side n c, the diameter c gives at b 4 the height of the diminished cylinder. Increasing side b a according to b c and striking the semicircle a 9 7, the point x b where the periphery cuts side n b yields one of the four sides of the lowered cylinder's base, enclosing a square of 9 cubes.
The base gains the fraction the height loses
If the cylinder is lowered by half, its base grows by half its first value; lowered a quarter, the base grows a quarter; lowered an eighth, an eighth; and if by seven eighths, the base gains 7/8. The thickness is then to be divided into as many irrational heights as can be given.
