Squaring the circle: lunes and a critique of Archimedes
Turning crescent lunes into equal squares, and why Archimedes' quadrature is 'well said and badly given'
This densely worked sheet pursues the quadrature of the circle through lunes, the crescent areas caught between arcs. Leonardo constructs four equal surfaces by turning lunes and circular sectors into rectilinear ('sided') figures that can be squared, reasoning with parallels, semicircles and portions labelled a, b, c, d and o p q. He analyses a quarter-circle sector as one-quarter of its circle and its sub-portions as 1/24, noting that a circle 24 times larger is needed to match six such portions. A marginal note judges Archimedes' quadrature 'well said and badly given': right in equating the circle to a right triangle of circumference and semidiameter, wrong in squaring a 96-sided figure that still omits 96 slivers.
On this page
Four equal surfaces from lunes and squares
Setting a equal to b and c to f, Leonardo shows the square d equal to the curvilinear lune e, then builds a squarable lune o p q by raising and lowering it within a semicircle. Removing the little portions leaves a 'sided' (rectilinear) figure that can be squared, yielding four equal surfaces in which c equals n and d equals q.
A parallel matching a sector's removed portions
Three marginal figures lettered a - b - c: draw the parallel b from a circle so that its removed portion equals all the removed portions of the sector c, with all of b first equal to all of c, and c equal to all of a.
A quarter-circle sector and its 1/24 portions
The sector c is one-quarter of a circle; a sub-sector taken as 1/6 of c is 1/24 of the whole circle. To find a sector whose portion equals the six portions of c, the new circle must be 24 times greater than c's circle.
Archimedes' quadrature 'well said and badly given'
Leonardo praises Archimedes for equating the circle to a right-angled triangle formed from the circumference and the semidiameter, but faults him for squaring a 96-sided figure from which 96 detached slivers are missing, which he says cannot properly be called a quadrature of the circle.
Two figures set equal (f c b a)
At the top, four figures lettered f c b a, with a and b set equal.
