Commensurable and Incommensurable Quantities
Arithmetic vs geometric proportion; surds and the square's diagonal (root of 200); Euclid, Book X
Folio 47v continues the proportion treatise, dividing arithmetic proportion into continuous (as 1-2-3, with equal excesses) and discontinuous (as 1-2, 5-6, 8-9). Leonardo then defines commensurable geometric quantities as those a single line measures exactly in both, and incommensurable ones as those admitting no common measure, giving the classic example of a square's diagonal against its side, which he cites Euclid's tenth book for; surd roots, he says, are incommensurable. He concludes that geometric proportion is of greater abstraction than arithmetic because it treats both rational and irrational, noting that if the side is 10 the diagonal is the root of 200, before turning to equality, inequality, and their simple and composite kinds. The page is closely written mirror-script with small numerical notes.
On this page
Commensurable versus incommensurable magnitudes
Commensurable geometric quantities are those measured exactly by one and the same line without remainder, as a one-foot line measures a two- and four-foot line. Incommensurable quantities admit no common measure, as between the diagonal of a square and its side, which Leonardo says can never be measured with precision by a single unit, citing Euclid's tenth book.
Surd roots and the diagonal as root of 200
Surd (irrational) roots are incommensurable and incommunicable, which is why geometric proportion, treating both rational and irrational, is of greater abstraction than arithmetic. If the side of a square is 10, its diagonal must be the root of 200.
Continuous and discontinuous arithmetic proportion
Continuous arithmetic proportion falls among at least three terms whose excesses are equal, as 1 2 3, showing the proportionality of equiparance where 1 is the excess by which 2 exceeds 1 and 3 exceeds 2. Discontinuous arithmetic proportion, as 1-2, 5-6, 8-9, is interrupted yet keeps its excesses in equiparance.
