The Paragone: Painting Outlives Music
Painting preserves beauty as the musician makes his own claim
The transcribed prose completes the comparison of harmony to the human body and then asserts that painting excels and lords it over music, because it does not die immediately after its making, as hapless music does, but remains a single surface that shows itself alive. It praises painting for preserving the fleeting beauties of mortals with more permanence than nature's own works, which time leads to old age. Section [30] then gives the musician's claim that his art composes a body of many members contemplated in harmonic measures, to which the painter replies that painting instead makes the harmony of proportioned members permanent for very many years. No drawing appears; only Melzi's fair-copy text.
On this page
Painting outlives music and preserves beauty
The passage holds that painting excels music because it does not perish immediately after creation like hapless music, but endures as a single surface shown alive. It marvels that this science preserves the fleeting beauties of mortals with more permanence than nature's works, which time continually alters and leads to their due old age.
The musician speaks with the painter [30]
Section [30] has the musician claim his art equals the painter's, since it composes a body of many members whose grace the listener contemplates through as many harmonic measures as it takes to be born and die. The painter answers that a body of human members gives no pleasure in changing measures where the beauty must be born and die, but painting makes that harmony permanent for very many years.
