Bas-relief's hidden difficulty and the sculptor's enemy: light
The painter commands two perspectives plus light and shade, which nature gives the carver
The painter learns sculpture sooner than the sculptor learns painting, Leonardo says, returning to bas-relief, which costs less bodily labour but far more investigation because it must judge the proportion of receding distances between the parts of bodies. He names the sculptor's "mortal enemy": lighting, since relief is worth nothing unless lit as it was wrought, and looks poor when lit from below. The painter, by contrast, commands the two perspectives and the further great discourse of the chiaroscuro of shadows and lights, of which the sculptor is ignorant and only aided by nature. The leaf is text only.
On this page
Bas-relief demands the proportion of receding distances
Bas-relief costs less bodily fatigue than the full round but far greater investigation, for one must weigh the proportion of the distances interposed between the first parts of bodies and the second, and from the second to the third. Judged by a perspectivist, no bas-relief is found free of errors in the greater and lesser relief of parts nearer or farther from the eye, whereas nature spares the full round such error.
Light from below, the sculptor's mortal enemy
A mortal enemy follows the sculptor in both full and low relief: his works are worth nothing unless they have light suited to them, like that in which they were wrought. Lit from below they look poor, and bas-relief above all almost cancels the knowledge of it under contrary lighting.
The painter's two perspectives and the light and shade unknown to the sculptor
This cannot befall the painter, who beyond placing the limbs has converted himself into the two greatest offices of nature, the two perspectives, and a third great discourse: the light and shade of shadows and lights. Of this the sculptor is ignorant, being aided only by nature as she aids other invisible artificial things.
