Paragone: Why Sculpture Is of Lesser Intellect Than Painting
Sculpture is bound to one light; painting alone renders colour, transparency and aerial perspective.
This page opens chapter 38 of the Trattato, in which Leonardo, claiming to practise both arts equally, judges painting superior to sculpture. He argues that sculpture depends on a single overhead light while painting carries its own light and shade everywhere, and that only painting can render colour, transparent and luminous bodies, mirrors, mists and aerial perspective. Sculpture's sole advantage, its resistance to time, he says is matched by painting fired in enamel on copper. The folio is entirely text in a clear humanist hand.
On this page
Only painting renders colour, transparency and aerial perspective
Leonardo argues that sculpture is bound to a single overhead light, while painting carries its own light and shade everywhere. Sculptors cannot vary the colours of things, nor show transparent or luminous bodies, mirrors, reflected lines, mists or dark weather, nor true aerial perspective. Painting, he claims, fails in no part whatever.
Sculpture's sole advantage: endurance in time
The one merit granted to sculpture is that it resists time better than painting. Yet Leonardo counters that painting laid on thick copper covered with white enamel, coloured with enamel and fused in the fire, endures for eternity and so surpasses sculpture even in permanence.
