Paragone: The Painter Adds, the Sculptor Only Removes
Nature gives the sculptor relief and light ready-made; the painter must win them by intellect.
Leonardo contrasts the sculptor, who only removes from one same material, with the painter, who adds many materials and must also render shade, light, colour and foreshortening. Nature gives relief, light and perspective to the sculptor ready-made, but the painter must win them by force of intellect and turn himself into nature herself. The page also describes artists who trace objects seen through glass or transparent veils, a shortcut Leonardo tolerates only in those already skilled by imagination. The folio is entirely text.
On this page
The painter must win by intellect what nature gives the sculptor
The sculptor only removes and seeks the lineaments that bound the material; the painter seeks those same outlines and, beyond them, shade, light, colour and foreshortening. Nature supplies relief, light and perspective to the sculptor ready-made, whereas the painter must acquire them by force of intellect and make himself into nature herself.
Drawing through glasses and transparent veils
Leonardo describes practitioners who, lacking science of shadow and perspective, trace objects seen through glasses or transparent veils, outlining them on the surface and filling the profiles with light and dark while noting the site and quantity of shadows. He allows the method only to those who otherwise know how to work from imagination and nature.
