On the Destructive Power of Rivers in Flood
A prose meditation ranking ruinous river floods above fire among earthly disasters
A page filled entirely with prose, written and reworked in dark ink, in which Leonardo argues that among all the powerful causes of earthly ruin the flooding of rivers holds the primacy, and not fire as some have claimed. He reasons that fire dies where its nourishment fails, while a river's destructive motion, sustained by the slope of united valleys, runs on until it reaches the sea. The passage then turns rhetorical, describing how swollen waves undermine mountains, tear down riverbanks, uproot trees and carry off the labours of the wretched farmers. A marginal heading reads 'tearing rivers.'
On this page
Floods set above fire among the causes of ruin
Leonardo places the inundation of ruinous rivers before every other fearful force, rejecting the view that fire's conflagration surpasses flood. Fire consumes what nourishes it and dies with its fuel, whereas the motion of water is sustained by the sloping, united valleys and continues until it ends in the sea, the universal lowness and sole repose of wandering river-waters.
Waves undermine mountains and strip the fields
With swollen and proud waves the river undermines high mountains, tears down the strongest banks, uproots deep-rooted trees, and, muddied, carries off from the cultivated fields the intolerable labours of the wretched and weary farmers. It leaves the valleys denuded and vile through the poverty left behind.
Marginal heading: 'tearing rivers'
In the right-hand margin a short heading labels the theme of the passage as the rivers that tear away. It names the destructive, rapacious character of rivers in flood that the surrounding prose develops.
