Squaring the Circle: Lunes and Circle-Portions
Five columns of quadrature studies — lunes, portions of circles, and the greatest inscribable square
A densely packed sheet of quadrature studies arranged in five columns, each pairing a small circle-and-square diagram with a mirror-written note. Leonardo repeatedly argues that the lunes and 'portions' cut from circles of double or quadruple proportion are together worth the greatest square that can be drawn from the larger circle, so that a curved figure can be shown equal to a rectilinear one. Recurring devices are the 'bi-angles' (lens shapes), lunes, semicircles, an inscribed helix, and rings, with the reasoning closed by appeals to Euclid-style rules about adding and removing equal parts.
On this page
Lunes and portions worth the greatest inscribable square
Removing the four greatest portions of the double circle equals removing the eight greatest of the sub-double circle. Once the four bi-angles are taken away, worth the sixteen portions into which the four greatest portions resolve, the remainder equals the largest square that can be drawn from the greater circle.
The cross a b c d and the leftover square
The cross a b c d together with the circular ring is worth the greatest square drawable from the larger circle, because 32 portions taken from the middle circle equal the four greatest portions of the larger one. Whatever of the larger circle is not occupied by those 32 portions is the square that remains once its four greatest portions are removed.
Sector equal to a semicircle: lune a equals portion b
With the sector a c set equal to the semicircle c b and their common contact at c, the lune a is proven equal to the portion b. Removing equal parts (c) from equals leaves equals, so two equal and similar surfaces are superimposed exactly one on the other.
Portions of circles in quadruple and sub-double proportion
Because the two circles stand double one to the other, the sixteen portions of the lesser (sub-quadruple) circle are worth the four greatest portions of the greater. The relations are governed throughout by simple ratios — double, quadruple and their halves — between the areas of the nested circles.
The helix as a squarable curved surface
Let there be a surface of uniformly non-uniform curvature equal to a rectilinear square. Leonardo states that such a surface is found in the helix, one of the curved figures he treats as reducible to a square.
Squarable remainder by the 'known minus known' rule
The ring with the diamond n is squarable, and the field remains squarable by the rule that if from a known quantity you remove a known part the remainder is known. The whole square being known and the ring-with-triangle n being known, the remainder is known and therefore squarable.
