Cracks in walls and the breaking of arches
Settling of mortar joints, straight versus oblique fissures, and an arch that breaks in five places
A continuation of Leonardo's treatise on why walls and arches fail. He reasons that stones walled with equal mortar settle equally as the binding moisture departs, that cracks are never parallel unless the separating part descends, and that lasting buildings must be raised uniformly at equal levels. A geometric proof shows that a semicircular arch loaded in its two opposite thirds breaks in five places, and further notes distinguish straight cracks (from new walls settling against old) from oblique ones, advising that walls be built before being faced with stone. Several diagrams show cracked brickwork, arches, and the new wall a b founded on the old wall c.
On this page
A semicircular arch breaks in five places under two loads
An arch made from a semicircle and loaded in its two opposite thirds by weights n and m breaks in five places of its curve. Since the ends c a are equally burdened, the break falls at the middle e most remote from the forces, and likewise on the opposite arch d g b; the weights cannot descend without drawing the arch's ends together, which cannot happen without breaking its middle.
Straight versus oblique cracks; build walls before facing them
Straight cracks are generated where new walls are joined to old ones by toothings that cannot resist the weight and must break, letting the new wall settle about one braccio in ten. Leonardo advises always building the wall first and only then facing it with stone, since a facing of larger stones takes less mortar and settles less, which cannot happen once the wall behind it is dry.
Equal mortar joints settle equally; the rule of permanent building
The small quantity of new wall between a n settles little compared with the greater quantity between c d, in proportion to the rarity and amount of mortar in the joints at various heights. The rule that makes buildings permanent is the contrary of these: raise all the walls equally, at equal levels, embracing the whole circuit of the building with the full thickness of every wall.
New wall a b settling over the stable old wall c
In the marginal case, a b is new wall and c is old wall that has already settled; a, being founded on the old wall c, cannot break, having a stable foundation. Only the remainder of the new wall b breaks, together with what is walled above it, making a corbel over the wall that descends.
