Does the moon shine by its own light or as a mirror?
The moon as a spherical mirror; its bright parts water, its dark parts land
This sheet argues that the moon has no light of its own but acts as a spherical mirror, illustrated by a circle marked as the sun casting rays onto a sphere labelled the moon-mirror, and by a lower diagram of the sun's rays falling on a row of small spheres. Leonardo asks how, if the moon were a smooth spherical mirror, it could show the broad splendour of the full moon, since a mirror reflects only a small image of a luminous body. He resolves that the shining part of the moon is water like our seas, made wavy, while the dark part is islands and dry land: countless little wave-crests each mirror the sun, and their highlights merge into one continuous glow. The demonstration ties astronomy to the optics of reflection in water.
On this page
Has the moon light of its own?
If the moon shone by itself it would not need the sun; if it does not, necessity makes it a spherical mirror. But a mirror shows only a small image of a luminous body, so how does the full moon, seen on its fifteenth day, give so great a quantity of splendour?
The bright moon is wavy water reflecting the sun
A smooth spherical mirror cannot shine over the whole extent the sun lights unless it is wavy or covered in little globes. As much of the moon as the sun sees, it makes shine; Leonardo concludes that what shines of the moon is water like our seas, made wavy, and what does not shine is islands and dry land.
Many sea-waves each mirror the sun
Just as each of many spheres set between eye and sun shows the sun's image, so each rounded wave of the sea mirrors the sun; at a distance the many highlights swell and merge, consuming the gaps between waves so the whole looks like one continuous sun, though dimmed where shadowy parts mix in.
