A bird with open wings cannot fall straight down
The centre-of-gravity argument against perpendicular descent, and the rudder analogy
A small bird with open wings is sketched (lettered c, f, e, d, b) amid dense notes rebutting an 'adversary'. Leonardo argues that a bird holding its wings fully open cannot fall backward, head-down, or straight down: since a freely falling body is led by its heaviest part, and here the heaviest part lies midway between the light wing-tips, perpendicular descent is impossible — the bird must descend obliquely along line a–b, and any small movement of wing or tail converts that oblique descent into reflex (upward) motion. He adds that large birds keep to great heights where the wind runs straight and strong, passing above the clouds to keep their feathers dry, and likens the small wing or tail movement that governs flight to the tiny motion of a rudder that turns a huge laden ship against wind and waves.
On this page
Why an open-winged bird cannot fall perpendicularly
The adversary claims a bird could descend edgewise along the line a–b with wings fully open. Leonardo answers that a freely falling body is guided by its heaviest part; here the heaviest part lies midway between the two light wing-tips, so straight descent is impossible. The bird must fall along an oblique line, and any small movement of wing or tail turns that oblique descent into reflex motion.
Large birds keep to great heights
Nature has set large birds high up, where the wind that aids their flight runs straight and powerful, away from the eddying, whirling winds of mountain gorges that could dash them on slopes, rocks and trees. At such height a bird always has time to right itself, and it passes above the clouds to avoid wetting its feathers.
The rudder analogy: a small cause, a great effect
As a small, almost imperceptible motion of the rudder can turn a ship of marvellous size, laden with the greatest weight and pressed by impetuous winds on its great sails, so a small motion of wing or tail is enough to send a soaring bird under or over the wind and prevent its descent.
